hi.
we stayed in calellalast june(booked to go again this june)
there was alot of building work going on around the st jordie,the car park opp,was a new hotel going up,and the large swimming pool was closing for new aparments,which would make the hotel seem very closed in.
sorry dont know about other hotel.
we stayed at the hotel mar blau, which is fantastic.
hope this helps angelica

http://www.holidaytruths.co.uk/reviews/spain/costa-brava/calella/sant-jordi-hotel/ For our hotel reviews of the Sant Jordi Hotel.

Why not visit both hotels in May and see whats going on , have a look around and then make your mind up , we very often do this and if its not very good at least it is our mistake and not the recommendations of others.

Ive just came back from he osaris in January I would highly recomend it as it has now been upgraded to 4 star and called the callela palace it is spottless and the meals are sperb you can also use any of the other h top hotels